The Imagined Library Books that were never written

Dream of the Red Chamber  ·  Chronicle

The Story of the Stone

also known as Dream of the Red Chamber; Honglou meng

A stone, copied by a Taoist; Cao Xueqin as editor

Can I actually read this? Yes. Someone printed it. You can buy a copy. Published in our world

The history of a sentient stone, left over from the repairing of the sky, that begged to see the world of red dust — copied off its own surface and read, in our world, as the great novel of a declining house.

Cervantes found an Arabic history in Toledo. Cao Xueqin found a stone.

The leftover block from Nüwa’s repair of the sky is the only object in this catalogue that is both the protagonist and the book. Baoyu lives; the stone records; a Taoist copies; an editor in the Qing dynasty takes the blame and the credit. Hawkes, translating, put The Story of the Stone on the English spine so that the frame would not be a preface you skip. He was right. The Rongguo garden is what the stone wanted when it asked to see the red dust. The novel is what it cost.

This is why it belongs with Cide Hamete and the Red Book, not with the Necronomicon. The fictional chronicle completed the journey into print. What you cannot hold is the inscription on the leftover jade. What you can hold is the house of Jia, in five volumes, which is the whole of the claim.

On the readability rating. Yes — of the transcription. The stone remains at the foot of the mountain, which is to say it remains in the first chapter.

In-world history

Nüwa mends the heavens and has one stone left over. The stone is given life, sent down, and lives as Jia Baoyu in the Rongguo house. A monk and a Taoist find the inscription of that life on the stone itself, at the foot of a mountain. Cao Xueqin, in the frame, works the text; Gao E and Cheng Weiyuan print it. What you hold is the transcription. What you cannot hold is the stone.

Why it matters

The Chinese founding of the found-manuscript. Before Cide Hamete, a stone. The published book insists it is not invented. It is recovered.

Appearances

  • Dream of the Red Chamber (1791) — Cao Xueqin Honglou meng; the frame is that the novel is the inscription on a discarded stone, transcribed and edited

Editions in our world

  • Honglou meng, Cao Xueqin (Cheng-Gao, 1791, and the manuscript tradition) Presented as the Story of the Stone. There is no stone. The real book is the one that taught Chinese fiction how to pretend a novel had been found — the Red Book arrangement, a century and a half earlier, in another script.

Connected volumes

Catalogue record

Category
Chronicle
World
Dream of the Red Chamber
Imagined by
Cao Xueqin
Language
Chinese
First appearance
Cheng-Gao printed edition, 1791; circulating in manuscript earlier
Readability
Published in our world

Sources

  • Cao Xueqin, Honglou meng (Dream of the Red Chamber / The Story of the Stone), Cheng-Gao edition 1791; English translation by David Hawkes and John Minford (Penguin, 1973–86), which restores the stone frame in the title.

Added by house · last checked 2026-09-06